The Bid & Ask

Quotations, Dispatches, and the Daily Tape

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Rejected thesis

Sector ETF mean-reversion

The result

Thesis (rejected): When a SPDR sector ETF closes ≥ 2 sigma below its 60-day mean and the broad market isn't in a tail move (|z_SPX| < 1.5), the ETF reverts 5-10 trading days later. Conrad / Kaul 1988 mean-reversion generalised to sector level.

Code: research/sector_reversion_validate.py Report: research/sector_reversion_report.json (n=203 events across 11 sector ETFs)

Why it failed: Hit rate is high (60-66 %) but edge over control is essentially zero - the reversion is generic market drift, not signal-specific alpha.

Horizon Event mean Ctrl mean Edge Hit
3 d +0.13 % +0.30 % −0.17 % 55 %
5 d +0.24 % +0.42 % −0.18 % 60 %
10 d +0.66 % +0.59 % +0.06 % 66 %
20 d +1.11 % +1.01 % +0.10 % 63 %

Sector ETFs at −2 σ are at −2 σ for macro reasons (a real sector headwind, rate move, etc.) and the dislocation persists. Going long the lagging sector earns roughly the same as buying any random day - we'd just be buying an upward-drifting index.

Verdict: Skip. The signal is dominated by macro persistence; the "mean reversion" assumption doesn't apply at sector-ETF level over 5-20 day horizons.


At a glance
Sample203
Validatorresearch/sector_reversion_validate.py
VerdictRejected

Every result here is reproducible from the script named above. Reports are in the repository.

Other rejected theses