The Bid & Ask

Quotations, Dispatches, and the Daily Tape

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Rejected thesis

Volume accumulation (above-200DMA + 20d-vs-90d volume spike)

The result

Thesis (marginal): Stocks in an established uptrend (above 200-day MA) with a sudden 20-day volume spike (z-score >= 1.0 vs the 90-day baseline) and confirming positive recent returns should continue for 20-40 days as institutional accumulation builds.

Code: research/accumulation_validate.py Report: research/accumulation_report.json (n=2,074)

Why we're parking it: Real signal but the magnitude is too small to support an options structure after frictions.

Horizon Event mean Ctrl mean Edge Hit
5 d +0.16 % +0.19 % -0.03 pp 55 %
10 d +0.40 % +0.29 % +0.11 pp 56 %
20 d +1.13 % +0.71 % +0.43 pp 57 %
40 d +2.54 % +1.66 % +0.88 pp 57 %

Hit-rate 57 % is real (significantly above coinflip on n=2,074) but the ~0.5-1 % edge per trade is too small for the options-spread framework that worked for bounce / coil / PEAD. After 30 % friction haircut, edge would round to zero in practice.

Verdict: Not added to the watch-list. Could be combined with other filters to amplify (e.g. accumulation + PEAD = stricter buy signal) but on its own the alpha is too thin.


At a glance
Sample2,074
Validatorresearch/accumulation_validate.py
VerdictRejected

Every result here is reproducible from the script named above. Reports are in the repository.

Other rejected theses