The Bid & Ask

Quotations, Dispatches, and the Daily Tape

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Rejected thesis

Failed-breakdown / bear-trap

The result

Thesis (modestly working only with drawdown): A close below the trailing 20-day low on volume, followed by a reclaim above that level within 1-3 days, marks a fake-out — shorts get squeezed and the price recovers.

Code: research/failed_breakdown.py Report: research/failed_breakdown_report.json (n=24,204)

Where it lands: same family as the broader contrarian set — unconditional edge is essentially 0 ; deep-drawdown sub-cohort produces +3.4 % at 40 d OOS but the magnitude is dominated by other triggers (RSI div, consensus, gap-cap).

Bucket n 20d edge 40d edge
all 24,204 +0.22 % -0.07 %
dd ≤ -30% 4,608 +1.74 % +2.83 %
OOS 2020+ dd ≤ -30% 2,981 +1.99 % +3.42 %

Verdict: Modest. Not productized as a standalone cohort but is one of the triggers feeding consensus_capitulation.


Working signals — discoveries from session 2

These were the most impactful findings of the second pass.

At a glance
Sample24,204
Validatorresearch/failed_breakdown.py
VerdictRejected

Every result here is reproducible from the script named above. Reports are in the repository.

Other rejected theses