The Bid & Ask

Quotations, Dispatches, and the Daily Tape

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Rejected thesis

Stage-2 trend gate (Weinstein / Minervini) as conditioning filter

The result

Thesis (CONFIRMED for two cohorts): Stage 2 — 50DMA > 150DMA > 200DMA with all three sloping up over the prior 20 days — should raise the per-event edge of a survivor pattern by selecting confirmed uptrends, the way relative_drawdown and vix_regime_overlay are used elsewhere in the repo.

Code: research/stage2_gate.py Report: research/stage2_gate_report.json (n=137,531)

Edges reported are unconditional (no controls subtracted) since the script re-uses each source event's own fwd_rets field.

Cohort × bucket n 10d 20d hit@20d
coil_breakout / all 937 +1.73 % +3.11 % 0.53
coil_breakout / Stage-2 408 +3.24% +4.72% 0.58
coil_breakout / NOT Stage-2 529 +0.57 % +1.86 % 0.50
vcp / all 1213 +0.16 % +0.59 % 0.55
vcp / Stage-2 652 +0.38% +1.25% 0.58
vcp / NOT Stage-2 561 -0.08 % -0.18 % 0.52
bull_flag / all 1332 +0.69 % +2.40 % 0.54
bull_flag / Stage-2 424 +1.17 % +2.24 % 0.54
bull_flag / NOT Stage-2 908 +0.47 % +2.48 % 0.53
pocket_pivot / all 134049 +0.32 % +0.67 % 0.54
pocket_pivot / Stage-2 86051 +0.30 % +0.64 % 0.54

Two clean wins, one neutral, one no-op:

  • coil_breakout gains a clean lift from Stage-2 (+4.7 % vs +1.9 %/20d, hit 0.58 vs 0.50). The non-Stage-2 portion is what drags the unconditional average down.
  • vcp is rescued from null by Stage-2 (+1.25 % vs -0.18 %/20d). Restores the Minervini context — VCP geometry only matters when the trend backdrop already says "uptrend".
  • bull_flag is unchanged by Stage-2 — the pole-and-channel geometry already implies a local uptrend, so adding an MA-stack requirement is redundant.
  • pocket_pivot still null inside Stage-2 — confirms the rejection above.

Verdict: Adopt Stage-2 as a stacking gate on coil_breakout and vcp. Skip for bull_flag (no lift) and pocket_pivot (null in both buckets).

At a glance
Sample137,531
Validatorresearch/stage2_gate.py
VerdictRejected

Every result here is reproducible from the script named above. Reports are in the repository.

Other rejected theses